Thursday, October 10, 2013

Student Centered, Principal Centered, Principle Centered Ethical Leadership


Principal Centered Leadership

School leaders’ roles are becoming more complex in the 21st century. A principal is not just the person that leads a school anymore. As an elementary school principal, I continuously play the role of counselor, nurse, social worker, coach, tutor, mother, etc. Flockton (2001) contends:
The role of principal can be liked in metaphor to that of the aircraft pilot. For much of the time you are fastened "up front" where you navigate, often unaided, times of turbulence and frustration; where you have to maintain a close eye on performance data clocked on the instrumentation, where you come to realise the importance of mission, vision and destinations, and where, on occasions of great satisfaction, you are able to feel and experience the joys and overwhelming sense purpose that derives from knowing that you are having a beneficial impact and making a difference among those whose efforts and, achievements you lead, guide, nurture and sustain. The sky offers boundless opportunities. Or does it? Because in looking to the sky, the principal knows all too well the realities of hard landings.
The role of the principal is a complex one, and not widely or fully understood. There are all manner of experts on how schools should be run (politicians, government administrators, academics, business leaders, accountants, lawyers, media commentators. ..to name a few) eager to give direction, advice, judgement, comment and counsel. Some of this is valid and well intentioned, but much can fail to apprehend the day to day realities of the job. Failure to apprehend, in my view, simply says that to know, one must actually endure sustained tenure as a school principal. The job is too frequently analysed, evaluated and advised by too many who have never had to do it. The role of principal is arguably burdensome, it is complex, it is not well understood. It can be, and should be, exceedingly satisfying - yet others can make it unreasonably demanding and overly exhausting. Most important, you are the people who, when exercising the great professional integrity of moral purpose, have the potential to realise the most potent influence over what is acceptable, and what is not acceptable, in teaching and learning. Teaching and learning is the core business of the school. Teaching and learning is the measure of the school. Teaching and learning demands highest priority in the thinking and leadership of the school principal. It is the real key to opening the way forward and making a difference in Tomorrow's Schools - if that difference is to be about students and opportunity to learn.

As a school principal, I have the moral obligation of providing my students, faculty, staff, and all stakeholders the best of everything. Principal leadership is synonymous with servant leadership, and collaborative leadership. A principal should demonstrate strong moral character, unquestionable ethics and integrity, and serve as a positive role model. The nucleus of principal leadership is the students. I can proudly state that I love what I do. My students are the most valuable and important aspect of my ministry, my calling. They are not a burden or a bother. The satisfaction I experience when I see them excited about learning makes every minute on campus worthwhile. As previously stated, principal leadership is also collaborative leadership. It involves sharing the leadership and power in order to move the organization forward. As a team, a vision and mission can be created, communicated, and executed. A team can establish a safe and orderly environment along with a positive culture and climate. The team can recruit highly qualified individuals that will provide a high quality education that focuses on the individual child. It can also monitor instruction to ensure students are receiving differentiated instruction as well as rigorous and relevant content. The team can also communicate high expectations and authentic care. Although the principal is accountable for everything that occurs on a school campus, the team plays a vital role in the success or failure of any organization.





Principal leadership is also “principle” leadership. Merriam Webster defines “principle” as “a moral rule or belief that helps you know what is right and wrong and that influences your actions; a rule or code of conduct.” As educational leaders, principals and teachers must lead with principles. Although the aforementioned may seem obvious, many people have indeed forgotten the obvious in pursuit of self-indulgence, perversion, and greed. Langvardt (2012) asserts,
To be effective teachers, leaders must be conscious of the examples they set. They also have to be skilled learners, in order to know what lessons to impart through their examples. They must learn not only from their own experiences but also from the experiences of others.
Far too many educational leaders have violated principles, oaths, and codes of ethics, which is a great disgrace. Although there has been a rise in criminal cases against school personnel, people do not seem to understand the implications of their actions on the entire school community. People have been caught having improper relationships with students, mishandling funds, tampering with exams, and so much more. We are supposed to be the positive role models our students can count on yet so many of us live like we were never taught the difference between right and wrong.


Stefkovich & Begley (2007, p. 210) argue that,
Because ethics are often interpreted in culturally exclusive ways, and do not require empirical evidence to justify their adoption, they can be a very troublesome category of values to employ as guides to action in our increasingly culturally diverse schools and communities where administrators increasingly sense the need to be accountable for their decisions. As a practical consequence school administrators naturally gravitate towards values grounded in rational consequence and consensus as guides to action and decision making whenever that is possible.

In addition, Stefkovich & Begley (2007, p. 220) “proposed a model that may serve as guide for making ethical decisions in the best interests of the student. The model consists of three elements: rights, responsibility, and respect.”
“Principle” leadership is all about “rights, responsibility, and respect.” Educational leaders must protect the rights of students and all stakeholders. They have a moral responsibility to follow all policies, rules, and laws, and must also respect themselves, the people they work with, and the profession.






Principal Leadership + Principle Leadership 
= Student Centered Leadership


Student Centered Leadership is all about the students. Their academic achievement is what drives campus improvement, planning, and budgeting. It is about catering to each individual child and catering to each need. Student centered leadership is about educating the whole child and preparing the student to be a successful, productive citizen. Starratt (2007, pp. 166-167) states,
Sometimes, perhaps most of the time, teachers forget that the youngsters in their classrooms have a rich, if complicated, life of their own. Neither the school, nor the teacher ‘owns’ them. They are not cardboard people, zombies patiently waiting to be programmed with the official ‘right answers’ by their teacher. What a school must do, and I pose this as an obligation if the moral character of learning is to be sustained, is to connect the learning agenda of the school to the central moral agenda of the learners during their 13 or more years in school, namely the agenda of finding and choosing and fashioning themselves as individuals and as a human community. As human beings they are searching, and must search for the truth of who they are. Teachers may suggest a connection between the school curriculum and the learners’ interests and experience, but that is often simply a ploy to motivate learners to absorb the academic curriculum so they can produce the prepackaged right answers to the academic assessments already pre-constructed. Tests are rarely ask for personal connections or commentaries; they want the curriculum rendered back in its pure academic form, as it was ‘delivered’ by the textbook and the teacher, untainted by personal associations.



Starratt makes a very important point. He stresses that we often educate students with the goal of them passing some type of assessment. With new state and federal mandates playing the role of school police, many schools leaders have shifted instruction from discovery learning and application to focusing on test taking skills and strategies. A school leader’s nightmare is having their school labeled “underperforming, unacceptable, or not meeting state standards.” Hence, learning is not fun for students anymore. Many of them do not want to go to school. It is imperative that we remember the reason we are doing what we are doing. Students first. Always. We need to afford students with the opportunity to experience learning in a way they can identify with. Learning must be meaningful, rigorous, relevant, and relationships play a critical role in the development of the child’s sociological needs. Student centered leadership involves doing everything in our power to ensure students do not leave our schools unprepared for what lies ahead. It is doing beyond the call of duty to make sure every student is successful in all areas of life and making sure they always have a smile on their face!



Resources

Langvardt, A. W. (2014). Ethical Leadership and the Dual Roles of Examples. Business
Ethics , 31.
merriam webster. (n.d.). Retrieved October 9, 2013, from merriam webster online:
www.merriam-webster.com
Starratt, R. J. (2007). Leading a Community of Learners: Learning to be Moral by
Engaging the Morality of Learning. Educational Management Administration &
Leadership , 166-167.
Stefkovich, J., & Begley, P. (2007). Ethical School Leadership Defining the Best
Interests of Students. Educational Management Administration & Leadership ,
210.


No comments:

Post a Comment